PURPOSE To compare information about fracture type in MRI with simple radiograph in tibial plateau fractures and evaluate tibial plateau fractures type and accompanying soft tissue injury, and evaluate usefulness of MRI in tibial plateau fractures. MATERIALS AND METHODS Compared MRI with simple radiograph about Schatzker classification, depression of articular surface and displacement of bone fragment from the 68 examples who checked MRI and we evaluated soft tissue injury around knee joint. RESULTS There were 7 examples of Schatzker type change after MRI check. Average depression of articular surface in simple radiograph was 2.93 mm and 4.28 mm in MRI. It increased by 1.35 mm and it was meaningful statistically (p<0.05). There was no significant difference between MRI and simple radiograph of displaced bone fragment (p=0.168). There were 58 (85.3%) cases of soft tissue injury in MRI. CONCLUSION MRI can find additional fracture line or articular depression that can't be found in simple radiograph and gives more information about articular depression and soft tissue that is useful in surgical plans. I think preoperative MRI is necessary to better treatment of fracture & treatment of periarticular soft tissue injury in tibial plateau fracture.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
The Use of Fresh Frozen Allogenic Bone Graft in the Impacted Tibial Plateau Fractures Yeung Jin Kim, Soo Uk Chae, Jung Hwan Yang, Ji Wan Lee, Dae Han Wi, Duk Hwa Choi Journal of the Korean Fracture Society.2010; 23(1): 26. CrossRef
PURPOSE The results of treatment of tibial plateau fractures by extensive soft tissue exposure were less satisfactory even if anatomical reduction was achieved. The purpose of this study is to assess the functional and radiological results of the treatment of tibial plateau fractures by cannulated screw fixation to decrease soft tissue injury and operation time. MATERIALS AND METHODS From January 1996 to February 2000, 19 patients were treated by limited open reduction and internal fixation by cannulated screw. According to scoring of Rasmussen, the functional results were rated. RESULTS In all cases, Bony union was obtained and according to scoring of Rasmussen, excellent in 1 case, good in 14, fair in 4 cases. There were 2 cases of limitation of joint motion and 2 cases of persistant pain as sequale. CONCLUSION We considered that if accurate preoperative evaluation was done, Cannulated screw fixaction was easier and faster method than other methods for treatment of tibial plateau fractures.
Severely depressed plateau fractures, especially Hohl I, III, can not be reduced by ligamentotaxis and require elevation through a cortical window, bone grafting, and fixation with either cancellous screws or a buttress plate. But traditional long lateral parapatellar incision and plate fixation method caused frequent wound dehiscence and deep infection. Thus to reduce the soft tissue problem we treated Hohl II, III plateau fractures by small anterolateral L-shaped incision, submeniscal exposure, reduction of depressed plateau and bone graft through bone window, and then cancellous screws fixation beneath the subchondral bone of elevated plateau. We anayzes 22 cases with Hohl II, III plateau fractures, which were treated by these method from February 1990 to December 1997 and followed more than 1 year. Males were 17, and females were 5. Average age of patients was 44.7 years. The most common cause of injury was traffic accidents(17 cases), and fracture type according to the Hohl classification was 14 cases of type II, 8 of type III. The associated injuries were 18 cases of meniscus tear, 13 of ligament injury(6 ACL, 7 MCL). The clinical results by Blokkers criteria were satisfactory 19 cases(86.3%) and unsatisfactory 3 cases(13.7%). We concluded that this method has following advantages; relatively firm fracture fixation, short operation time, low soft tissue problem.